Film review by Gordon Justesen
Technical specs by Michael Jacobson
Eric Bana, Jennifer Connelly, Sam Elliott, Josh Lucas, Nick Nolte
Director: Ang Lee
Audio: DTS HD 5.1, Dolby Digital 2.0
Video: Anamorphic Widescreen 1.85:1
Features: See Review
Length: 138 Minutes
Release Date: September 16, 2008
making me angry.”
Make no mistake
about it. Of all characters to grace the pages of comic books, The Hulk has
probably been the most highly anticipated in terms of being brought to the big
screen, next to Spider-Man. When
audiences packed in the multiplex's to see Spidey's feature film debut, they
were given a first glimpse of what was to come the following year.
The brief teaser
was quite a stunner. It showed a shivering man looking at himself in the mirror,
looking as if he was trying fight some kind of emotion trying to take control
over him, which indeed it was, as we saw his eyeball turn a monstrous green. It
rocked the audience at the screening I atteneded, illustrating that many fans of
The Hulk had waited very long for the angry green giant to make it to the big
screen. When it was revealed that Ang Lee was going to direct the movie, my
expectations soared even higher.
A year later, Hulk
landed in theaters, and was met with perhaps the most extraordinary level of
mixed reaction of any movie of recent memory. Many film critics praised the
film, lauding Ang Lee's vision of the eccentric Marvel hero as a modern day
Frankentstein, with a touch of Greek tragedy. At the same time, this somewhat
artistic gesture is what turned off those who were seeking a non-stop bombastic
thrill ride, a la Spider-Man and Daredevil. This is possibly the most dark superhero movie I, for
one, have ever experienced.
As for me, my
opinion falls somewhere in between, but more on that further down the road. What
I will eagerly state is that there is a lot to admire about what Ang Lee has
done with this material. Many will note that Lee films have no relation in terms
of genres, and he likes to try something new. Hulk is indeed Lee's most ambitious project to date, filled with
both highs and lows.
The centerpiece, of
course, is the character of modern-day nuclear scientist Bruce Banner, played
with perfected ease by Eric Bana. Banner is a man plagued by not knowing much
about his past, even though he admits that both his parents have long been dead.
But that soon proves to be nothing of the case when Bruce's father, David Banner
(Nick Nolte), turns up to spy on his son's every move, and for bizarre reasons.
The older Banner
was once a military scientist. As revealed in an opening prologue, which briefly
chronicles the father's science work as well as Bruce's eventual birth, the
father did the unthinkable when he passed along tampered DNA genes to Bruce when
he was an infant. Needless to say, the elder Banner, who is obviously a deranged
mad scientist, is awaiting the birth of something…well…bigger.
comes to acknowledge this troubled gift, following a lab accident that has
indeed triggered the very specific genes altered in his youth. This, of course,
leads to the young scientist's discovery of his inner hulk, a transformation
process triggered by pure rage.
plot note is Bruce's unique relationship with co-worker and former flame Betty
Ross (Jennifer Connelly). Despite not being able to spark a romantic fling, the
two remain very close. In fact, she feels more close to him than ever as a
companion, a thorn that doesn't sit well in her father's side. Betty's father is
the stern General Ross (Sam Elliott) who was an adversary of Bruce's father and
doesn't much care for the offspring, especially when the alter ego is revealed.
As I mentioned
earlier, there is a whole lot to admire here, all of which can be credited to
Ang Lee's unique vision. What Lee has brought to this interpretation, in terms
of comic book essence, is quite simply bold and superb. Staging many key scenes
in a spilt-screen-like format, with images seen from different points of view,
Lee has incorporated the look and feel of a comic book onto the screen, which is
very much a treat for the eyes.
Much was made about
the movie's special effects surrounding the look of the Hulk. Many felt the
computer generated effects made the Hulk appear like an all too obvious computer
generated effect. I didn't have a problem with the look of the Hulk, mainly
because the movie is clearly a representation of the original comic book
character, which was lifelike in size and shape. To have another actor play the
Hulk, as in the popular 70s television show, would've been the wrong move for
the movie. An elaborate standoff between the Hulk and military forces is a
show-stopping moment, and comes very close to saving the film.
does have a few flaws too many that cause it to not be the success it should've
been. Its main flaw is that of story construction, most notably in the later
portions of the film. A good percent of the film has Bruce/the Hulk secured at a
discreet military base/laboratory, which eventually leads to the military's
pursuit of the monster. At the same time, a subplot involving Bruce's father
plotting to upgrade his DNA cells doesn't make much sense, and it leads to a
standoff between Bruce and the father in a section of the movie that feels a bit
tacked on and unnecessary, although the two's confrontation is somewhat
So, for me, in the
end, Hulk is a mixed bag. Some
applauded it for being a different take on your typical superhero movie, while
others blasted it for being too talkative and slow moving. I, however, am in
that rare position of being mixed, though I do think there's plenty to enjoy
here. I feel that with a bit more tightening on the editing and story handling,
we really could've had something here.
BONUS TRIVIA: Look
closely and you'll spot Hulk creator Stan Lee and former television Hulk Lou
Ferrigno as security guards.
Universal has been doing an incredibly consistent job with their Blu-ray releases. For some reason, even though I wasn't a huge fan of the movie, Hulk was one of the titles I most wanted to see in Blu-ray. It didn't disappoint. Though the big guy is a little artificial looking, the bright green really stands out with detail and contrast in this high definition transfer. The light and dark scenes balance well, with sharp crisp images and vivid color presentation, even with the many night settings.
The DTS HD soundtrack is incredible, no pun intended. The action and fury of such a superhero movie makes for a dynamic and expansive listening experience, with powerful bass and nicely consistent surround usage. Spoken words are clean and clear against the bedlam of sound effects and Danny Elfman's solid score.
Plenty of goodies on this loaded Blu-ray. Included is a commentary with Ang Lee, deleted scenes, and five featurettes: "The Making of Hulk", "Evolution of Hulk", "The Unique Style of Editing Hulk", "The Incredible Ang Lee", and "The Dogfight". And what Universal Blu-ray release would be complete without "U-Control"? It offers you one-click access to picture-in-picture bonuses while you watch the movie for extra interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
I've hardly been has mixed on a single movie as I am with Hulk. I commend Ang Lee for breathing some life into this superhero tale, but I just wish certain elements had been either rearranged or removed to make a much tighter film.