Review by Michael Jacobson
Stars: Bob Hoskins, Cathy Tyson, Michael Caine, Katie
Director: Neil Jordan
Audio: DTS HD 5.1
Video: Anamorphic Widescreen 1.85:1
Studio: Image Entertainment
Length: 104 Minutes
Release Date: August 24, 2010
"Haven't you ever needed someone?"
"All the time."
Like the legendary painting that bears her name, Neil Jordan’s film Mona Lisa is a work of art that intrigues with a smile that suggests it’s hiding something. There are many surprises along the way to pepper this moving character study, and Jordan delights in revealing them to us at the same time he reveals them to his antagonist.
That character is George (Hoskins), whom we first see making the long walk back to his home after his release from prison. He carries the infamous little brown package of all the belongings that went into the institution with him, and he seems small and almost lost against the much larger background of London. His first real human encounter is when he shows up at his ex-wife’s flat, hoping to refresh his relationship with his now nearly grown daughter. It’s an immediate fiasco for him.
George is returning to a criminal world that has changed since he first went to jail over seven years ago. He shows up at the headquarters of his old boss Mortwell (Caine) ready to work again. He finds himself with a job as a driver for a high priced black call girl, Simone (Tyson). They are as mismatched as you can get: she is, despite her occupation, a woman of class and taste. George is, by his own admission, “cheap” and unrefined…and perhaps even a bit of a bigot.
What keeps George on the edge is his naivety about the world that Simone occupies; a world that she’s wholly cool about, but seems poised to shock and horrify the baffled George at every corner. As her driver, he’s also her protector, a job he has the muscle but not the sense for.
The most obvious route Jordan could have taken would be for these characters to fall in love, but there’s an interesting twist: George and Simone have mismatched needs, and while George does begin to fall for her, the problem is that she can’t fulfill his needs, nor he for her.
The emotional attachment he begins to develop brings him into a new development, when Simone pleads his help in finding another prostitute that used to work with her under an abusive pimp. Simone got out, Cathy (Hardie) did not. Now that Simone has evolved into an independent (and financially well-off) woman, she wants to help her old friend. George finds himself on a journey into hell, of sorts. He drives down dark streets where the hookers emerge from the darkness toward his car like lost souls in the river Styx, and at the end of that road is the seediest district of London—a world of strip clubs and peep shows, where George mutters about some of the girls “I’ve got a daughter that age!”.
As mentioned, there is more to this film than initially meets the eye. George is successful in bringing Cathy to Simone, but his actions don’t make him a hero in her eyes…it turns out there was an entirely different motive altogether behind her request. George’s frail visions begin to unravel, especially when he finds that his sleazy boss Mortwell really gave him the driver’s job so he could dig up dirt on both Simone and her clients.
There are other surprises that I’ll leave for you to discover…each one is a satisfying twist that keep the film moving towards its harsh and possibly inevitable finale. This is a taut, well scripted and masterfully directed film from Jordan, whose clear vision about his characters and the world they occupy make for an engrossing story. Just the concept of the heavy protector being more lost and naïve than the prostitute he works for opens up the film for numerous possibilities, and Jordan doesn’t fail to explore them.
Bob Hoskins’ performance is stunning. He’s one of our best character actors, and he delivers the best work of his career here as George, bringing to the screen all the subtle nuances of a complex human being whose outdated ideas are setting him up for emotional destruction. His Oscar nomination for this movie was well deserved. Also good is Cathy Tyson in her first film role—pretty and cool, she is in some ways the kinder version of the classic femme fatale image. It is not really her that breaks George, but rather his vision of her.
“Do men fall in love with you?” he asks at one point. Her cautious reply: “They fall in love with who they think I am.” And then, sadly enough, George does exactly the same thing.
Image has done well by one of my favorite 80s films. The high definition transfer brings out better coloring and contrast than have been seen in previous DVD editions. Some grain here and there is visible owing to the film stock, which in many cases was high contrast stock for low light scenes, but overall, the crispness and clarity is terrific to behold.
The original mono has been enhanced for DTS 5.1 sound...it's not a particularly daring mix; I noticed very little from the rear stages throughout, but the dialogue and music beds are both well handled, and the overall presentation is cleanly done.
Features (zero stars)
Mona Lisa is a dark, absorbing masterpiece of a character drama: brilliantly acted and boasting a superb script and sense of direction. It’s an unconventional story of two dark characters thrown together in a mix that might have led to romance, except for their incompatible ideals and mismatched needs. It's been a favorite of mine for a long time, and I for one enjoyed the chance to re-visit it on Blu-ray.